The Educational Technology Site: ICT in Education
THE site for leaders and managers of educational ICT

Articles Home Page 

Main Website Home Page


  Enter your email to receive
  the latest article summaries

 
  Preview | Powered by FeedBlitz

  Subscribe to article summaries
  Subscribe to full articles
  Subscribe to our podcast


Thoughts & tips for the day

Seesmic Updates

(Loading ...)

feed-icon-14x14 Subscribe to the videos

My recent activity

Recent Comments

My latest del.icio.us bookmarks

 
 Website guides
 
 News & Views
 
 Using & Teaching Educational Technology
 Checklist: using ed tech
 
 Leading & Managing Educational Technology
 Practical ICT eJournal
 
 Computers in Classrooms
 Latest + downloads
 Past issues
 
 Weekend

Locations of visitors to this page

Using & Teaching Educational Technology


A Code of Ethics
By Terry Freedman
Created on Thu, 24 Aug 2006, 07:53

Email this article
 Printer friendly page
Email the author

David Warlick has produced a Code of Ethics, and Stephen Downes disagrees with the idea. Stephen Downes is both right and wrong.

In an interesting example of synchronicity (or perhaps mere coincidence), David Warlick and I have covered similar ground this week: I in my article entitled  "Asking the right questions" and David in his (earlier) article entitled  "Getting Right Down To It". David's is the more comprehensive.

One would have thought that there is little to take issue with over a code of ethics that includes headings such as "Seek Truth and Express It" and "Be accountable", yet Stephen Downes has done so, in a recent post, in which he questions both the usefulness of such a Code and the
implications of some of its details.

He states that in his view "a code of ethics is not useful, because if one believes in the ethics, the coded is not needed, and if one doesn't, the code will not be followed." This is similar to Shankara's  dictum that "to an unenlightened person, the Scriptures are meaningless, and to an enlightened person, the Scriptures are useless."

Shankara was right, of course, but that doesn't prevent people finding their own Scriptures both meaningful and useful. Downes may be correct in a logical sense, but I don't see how his position actually helps anyone working in schools.


He goes on to disagree with Warlick's appeal to question the sources' motives: "No, because the motives are often irrelevant." Well, perhaps they are "often" irrelevant, but that implies they are sometimes relevant -- and as you don't know in advance which is the case, surely it is right to question the sources' motives?

Bizarrely in my view, Downes also disagrees with the clause "Never use information from another person without proper citation and permission?", stating: "A bad principle; I would not be able to criticize most people and companies." Surely the starting point is to instil the ethical value of citing sources with permission, before bringing in the obvious exceptions?

I have not studied philosophy or logic, so I am happy to give Downes some benefit of the doubt. But my main concern is the practical business of enabling schools to develop their students' abilities to not merely survive, but to thrive, in the so-called flat world in which we live. What we need are strategies and guidelines, not theoretical arguments which have no practical value that I can see.


What do you think? Please leave a comment.

© Terry Freedman Thu, 24 Aug 2006


Comments are moderated.
If you found this article useful,  share it with a colleague.

Say "Hi" to me on Twitter! I am at http://www.twitter.com/terryfreedman
Don't miss out on the developments concerning "Coming of Age..." the FREE book about using Web 2.0 tools in the classroom!







Articles on e-learning and information & communication technology containing practical advice for subject leaders
Top of Page

Weblog Commenting and Trackback by HaloScan.com
Headlines by category
Latest articles by category




.  


Website guides
Guide to the Educational Technology: ICT in Education Website
QuickStart Guide to the Educational Technology: I.C.T. in Education Site
Website Guide: Getting Content for Your Website
News & Views
Collaborative Projects
Practical ICT September Edition out now!
A break in the madness!
Using & Teaching Educational Technology
Doing our bit against poverty
Eyes on the street
What does an IT consultant do?
Leading & Managing Educational Technology
Decision-making in a crisis
Decision-making in a complex environment
Shock Tactics
Computers in Classrooms
Computers in Classrooms June 2008
"Technology's Promise and Me", "MySpace and I, What Video Games Have to Teach Us About Learning and Literacy. Second Edition: 20% off for subscribers to "Computers in Classrooms"
Computers in Classrooms April 2008
Weekend
Change management #5: People can do it for themselves
Change Management #4
Change management #3